OOIDA Will Appeal Ruling in PA Turnpike Case

The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association will appeal a ruling announced in a class-action lawsuit regarding tolls on users of the Pennsylvania Turnpike

The lawsuit was brought last year by OOIDA and the National Motorists Association in the federal court in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. The associations made up of truck drivers and other motorists challenged the constitutionality of the excessive tolls imposed upon drivers on the Pennsylvania Turnpike.

Today, Judge Yvette Kane granted the motions to dismiss of the defendants, which included the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission, Governor Tom Wolf, and Leslie Richards, Pennsylvania’s Secretary of Transportation.

OOIDA expressed disappointment over the ruling, but is clearly not discouraged. 

In the opinion, the judge acknowledged that plaintiffs’ complaint “credibly alleges that Pennsylvania’s policy decisions related to transportation have resulted in a statutory scheme that disproportionately burdens Turnpike travelers with the costs of a state-wide transportation system that is of no direct benefit to them.”

“It’s pretty clear she understands the situation,” noted Todd Spencer, President of OOIDA. “But she also stated quite clearly that no definitive controlling precedent supports either side.”

“It appears to us that she chose to apply a standard from a Supreme Court case from back in 1970 that focused on burdens imposed under a state’s regulations about agricultural products, rather than a standard from more recent in Supreme Court cases that spoke directly to user fees, which is what the tolls are in Pennsylvania,” said Spencer.

The Association says the case is now poised for review by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals.

“Our case has been widely reported in the press and incorrectly linked with other reports alerting the public to a looming transportation crisis, driven in part by the same statutory scheme that our lawsuit challenges,” said Spencer.” 

Act 44 and 89, passed in 2008 and 2013 respectively, ordered the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission to send $450 million a year to PennDOT.  The Turnpike is in debt approaching $12 billion, and the Auditor General has labeled the state’s transportation funding system “unsustainable.”
“This lawsuit is far from over,” Spencer continued.  “And win or lose on appeal, the turnpike’s debt crisis and the Commonwealth’s transportation emergency aren’t going away either. This is a crisis created by the legislature’s decisions, not our lawsuit.”

Category: Driver Stuff, Featured, General Update, News